If you thought the painful lessons of the last interest rate cycle had permanently scared Canadians away from variable-rate mortgages, think again.
According to recent data from National Bank, nearly half of all Canadians taking out or renewing a mortgage in 2026 opted for a variable rate by September. To put that shift into perspective, that figure was sitting at under 10% back in 2024.
In a twist of unfortunate timing, that massive rush into variable rates happened right before the Bank of Canada pivoted back to hiking rates. Given how badly this exact trade ended for borrowers during the previous hiking cycle, it begs an obvious question: Why are so many homebuyers doing it again?
The Allure of the Spread
The answer comes down to simple math and affordability pressure. Right now, the spread between variable and fixed rates looks almost too good to pass up:
Bullet Best 5-Year Variable Rate: 3.65%
Bullet Best 5-Year Fixed Rate: 4.44%
That 79-basis-point gap isn't just saving borrowers money on paper; for many buyers, it is the sole reason they are able to qualify for a mortgage in today's market. When budgets are stretched thin, taking the lower initial rate feels like the only way to get the keys.
How Quickly That Discount Can Vanish
The problem with chasing the spread is that variable rates don't stay static and the central bank is already moving against borrowers.
On October 28, the Bank of Canada hiked its policy rate to 2.5%. Economists and markets are now pricing in another hike before the end of this year, followed by up to three more hikes by the end of 2027.
Let's look at what happens if those forecasts play out:
Bullet Three quarter-point hikes = 75 basis points.
Bullet Add 75 basis points to a 3.65% variable rate, and you are suddenly sitting at 4.40%.
In a matter of months, the entire discount you had over a 4.44% fixed rate is effectively wiped out and you’re left exposed if rates climb any higher.
Can You Actually Afford the Deal?
There is nothing inherently wrong with a variable-rate mortgage, provided you are choosing it for the right reasons.
If you have a healthy financial buffer, strong cash flow, and the flexibility to absorb higher monthly payments without losing sleep, going variable can still be a calculated, strategic move.
However, if a variable rate is the only way you can qualify for a mortgage or make the monthly numbers work, you probably can't afford the house. Stretching your budget to the absolute limit on a variable rate isn't a financial strategy, it’s betting your home on geopolitics, stubborn inflation, and Bank of Canada Governor Tiff Macklem's next move.

